ago, on the evening of 30th April 1999, that the Admiral Duncan in Soho's famous Old Compton Street was the scene of a bomb blast
that killed three people and wounded around 70. The bomb was the third that had been planted by Neo-Nazi David Copeland, who was attempting to stir
up ethnic and homophobic tensions by carrying out a series of bombings.
On this significant anniversary, we remember that horrific event by hearing from Michael Murphy
who followed the trial of this racist homophobe at the UK's principal criminal court.
Copeland had tried to fool doctors into sending him backing to prison - rather than remaining in Broadmoor - by pretending he was not
ill. Dr Gilluley said Copeland had insisted he considered himself a heterosexual.
But when he was 13 his parents became "funny" towards him,
inferring he was a homosexual. He said he was "extremely angry" with his parents
for making him see a doctor because they were worried about his slow growth. The doctor
had examined his genitals.
Dr Gilluley thought Copeland's personality began to change when he was 19
and isolated himself from his family and friends.
He said: "He told us he began to realise he had a mission. He said
that during this time all he wanted to do was to kill people.
"He said he considered using a gun but said he could not do this
because he would be arrested and it would prevent him from carrying out his destiny to
plant a bomb."
|
Bomb Aftermath
|
Later, the jury was treated to conflicting psychiatric evidence to Copeland's state of mind. The court
heard how Copeland dreamed about the day he would appear in court, a prosecution doctor
told the Old Bailey.
|
"There was no suggestion of any concern or stress. He was
exceptionally calm. He seemed very positive about going to court," said police
surgeon Dr Peter Dean. During one of four interviews Copeland told him:
"I planned this. I have been dreaming about it for ages - doing what I did, getting
caught, going to court - it is my destiny."
Dr Dean said he had found no suggestion whatsoever of any delusions or
hallucinations or thought disorder when he examined Copeland. "He put it down to
stress," Dr Dean told the court, "and just having a shit life."
He also blamed his parents for taunting him about his suspected
homosexuality. Copeland told doctors that his parents would often sing the theme tune to
'The Flintstones', emphasising the line, 'We'll have a gay old time.'
As the trial entered its third week, it was revealed how the nail-bomber
fell in love with a woman who wrote to him in prison after his arrest. But "Patricia
Scanlon" was really a male journalist who fooled Copeland into corresponding with him
about his trial.
|
Copeland told "Patsy" he had fallen in love with her and offered to send her a clock for
Christmas to "remind" her of him, adding, "tick tock." In another
letter, he said: "I cannot believe I have fooled all the doctors."
Defence psychiatrist, Dr Ian Cummings, said that when Copeland carried out
his bombing campaign, he falsely believed he would create a race war and would be
rewarded.
"He believed God had chosen him and an Armageddon might result,"
stated Dr Cummings. He informed the court that Copeland had started taking medication early this year "and there had been a small improvement."
|
David Copeland
|
On the morning of Wednesday, June 25th, Nigel Sweeney began summing up for
the prosecution. He told the jury that the Crown had proved that Copeland had intended to
kill people during his bombing campaign: "It is a clear case of murder," said Mr
Sweeney. "He was not suffering from mental illness during the bombings. He made a
choice, took that choice, and he should now pay for his choice."
|
Dismissing the defence's claim of diminished responsibility, Mr Sweeney
said that Copeland had changed his story several times, with "no references to
delusions or hearing voices until much later."
He called on the jury to return a guilty verdict for the three murders.
|
In the afternoon, as the sun shone through the skylight of Court Number
One, Michael Wolkind summed up the defence case. He recounted the evidence given by the
five defence psychiatrists, concluding that Copeland was "a paranoid
schizophrenic" who could not be held to account for the consequences of his actions.
Before concluding, Mr Wolkind lambasted the psychiatric evidence presented
by the prosecution, in particular singling out Dr Joseph, whose testimony he contended was
"neither reliable or fair."
|
Soho Victim
|
Summing up on Thursday morning, The Recorder of London, Judge Michael Hyam asked the jury to consider if
Copeland is guilty of murdering Andrea Dykes, 27, Nicholas Moore, 31, and John Light, 32,
in the Soho blast last year.
|
Copeland with BNP's John Tyndall
|
The defence had argued that Copeland was suffering from paranoid
schizophrenia at the time of the bombings.
But prosecution psychiatrist Dr Philip Joseph had earlier told the court
he believed Copeland was suffering from a personality disorder, which did not impair his
responsibility.
In his summing up, the Recorder of London, Judge Michael Hyam, told the
jury they had one issue to decide - "whether the defendant was suffering from
diminished responsibility at the time of his attacks."
|
He asked the jury to decide if the defence had proved that David
Copeland's "responsibility for his acts was substantially diminished by reason of an
abnormality of mind".
The jury retired to deliberate on the murder charges at 3.20pm. An hour
and ten minutes later the jury had still not come to a decision, and they were sent under
escort to a hotel where they were to spend the night.
A little over twenty-four hours later, at 3.23pm on Friday, 30th June,
proceedings reconvened in Court Number One when the jury had indicated they had concluded
their deliberations.
|
The silence was deafening as the jury filed into their benches on the
left-hand side of the courtroom. The court was packed to capacity with victims and press
hacks alike all vying for the 'best seats' from which to witness this long-awaited moment.
As the clerk read aloud the three charges of murder against Copeland to
the jury the foreman replied "Guilty" to all three counts on the indictment.
As the verdicts sunk in, huge cheers rang out from victims seated at the
back of the court, followed by shouts of "Murdering bastard!" and "Nazi
scum" reining down on Copeland from the public gallery above.
Addressing Copeland, who stood in the dock maintaining a scowl of
contempt, Judge Michael Hyam told him: "Anyone who has heard the facts of this case
will be appalled and horrified" at the atrocities he had committed.
|
He said: "You were motivated by virulent hatred and pitiless contempt. set out to
kill, maim and cause terror and you have left three families bereaved. They are constantly
reminded that you alone are responsible.
"Nothing can excuse or justify the evil and the abhorrent views you
express."
Sentencing Copeland to a total of six life sentences, Judge Hyam told him:
"The public must be protected from you and it must be assured that you are not
released for a very long time."
|
Copeland's bedsit
|
As the jury were discharged, a spontaneous and dignified round of applause
broke out from the rear of the court, at first quietly, quickly spreading audibly to the
public gallery as Copeland's twelve peers were led from the Courtroom. The atmosphere of
the court had been transformed in those few seconds from a sombre, silent occasion to that
of a soccer stadium after the home team has scored a match-winning goal.
Copeland was led down to the cells from where he later returned to
Broadmoor's top security hospital to continue his treatment.
|
Outside the court, Chris Walker, London area manager of Scottish &
Newcastle brewers, owners of the Admiral Duncan, said: "We are pleased with the
outcome of the trial. I believe the jury made the right decision and I am relieved the
ordeal of the court proceedings are over.
"The trial is over but those who were caught up in this terrible
tragedy will continue to live with the memory of what happened on April 30th. My thoughts,
as ever, are with the families of those who lost their lives in this terrible tragedy and
with all those who have suffered as a result of this horrific bombing.
"I would like to add my sincere thanks to everyone who has offered
their support and encouragement to Mark and his staff over the last fourteen months. It
has been overwhelming at times, but it has meant a great deal to all of them."
The father of nail-bomber David Copeland
condemned the murder of the three people who died and the other 129 who were injured in
the three blasts.
From behind the closed doors of his home in the leafy village of Yately,
Hants, Stephen Copeland, 50, told Michael Murphy he would wash his hands of his son if he
was found guilty of the three murders. The tearful dad-of-three, a heating engineer,
refused to come to the door of the £200,000 family home, saying he had been told he
"could be in danger".
Speaking through an intercom system, he said: "Myself and my
family totally condemn the cowardly and barbaric bombings carried out in London. Our
heartfelt thoughts and sympathies go out to the families of the bereaved and those
injured, who are grieving at this time.
|
The Admiral Duncan Plaque
Photo: Spudgun67
CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
|
"If David is guilty of these awful acts of violence, then we totally
condemn him for carrying them out.
"As you can imagine, we are all completely devastated by these
events. We cannot begin to imagine how terrible the families of the killed and injured
must be feeling today.
"We are all mystified to learn that David could be responsible for
all these bloody bombings. We wish to be left in peace at this time. I have nothing else
to say at the moment."
|
On 2 March 2007, the High Court decided that David Copeland should remain in prison for at least 50 years,
ruling out his release until 2049 at the earliest, when he would be in his seventies. Copeland appealed this decision
on 28 June 2011, but the Court of Appeal upheld the ruling.
Just over 10 years ago he was placed in solitary confinement after a brutal attack on a fellow prisoner. The victim
was savagely beaten in a fight at high-security HMP Belmarsh in south-east London.
In June 2014, Copeland attacked another fellow inmate at HM Prison Belmarsh with a shiv, an improvised weapon made
from razor blades attached to a toothbrush handle. In October 2015, he pleaded guilty to wounding with intent and was
sentenced to a further three years in prison, of which he will serve 18 months.
There is still almost 25 years of his original 50 year sentence remaining. Together with his additional sentence
he won't be considered for release until he is at least 75 years old.
Return to First Page
|
|